After playing Pin the Tail on the Pony, we played Hoopla. Here I combined a pre-bought set with some empty bottles in a little crate. The kids all stood in a row and took turns trying to throw the hoops around the necks of the bottles - and I kept tally.
GOOD TIP - if you don't have hoops, you can still play a game of toss, by throwing theme appropriate goodies into empty buckets.
The Pony Party Series